Showing posts with label Totalitarianism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Totalitarianism. Show all posts

Monday, March 11, 2013

On Bosses and Daddies

So, you may recall a few weeks back that Chris Rock said that President Obama was like the country's boss and daddy.  Setting aside the colossal irony (think about who said it) and stupidity of such a statement, his word choice actually deserves a bit more analysis than its shallowness suggests.

That statement reveals one of the big differences between how conservatives and progressives think.

Julius Caesar.
Something everyone should understand is that throughout most of history, governments have owned their people.  Not in the strictest sense, as a master would a slave, but close to it.  Governments had expectations and required duties of their people without any reciprocal expectations from those people.  Kings could tax their populations into poverty and levy them for war without the people's consent recourse.  More recently, the regimes of facists and communists curbed freedoms, demanded work and often pointless fighting for the state.  This has held true throughout history and continues in most nations today.

This is a major reason why America has been different from nearly every nation that has existed on the Earth.  For in America, we are not lorded over by nobles, senators, councilmen, kings or ayatollahs.  We are in charge of them.  We are responsible for electing them and keeping them in check (whether or not this is true in practice is another matter).  Our government is there, with our consent, to keep an orderly, lawful society, for no one denies that laws, diplomats and militaries must exist.

However, no one rules over us nor do we need anyone to do so.  We accept that we are free peoples who can make decisions for ourselves, for good or for ill.

Napoleon Bonaparte.
For the progressive, it is the exact opposite.  They think collectively, as most people around the world have and continue to do.  They see people (besides themselves, naturally) as requiring, if not demanding, someone to rule over them.  They see the country and its people as needing a boss to control it and direct it.  They believe that without the guidance of some "benevolent" ruler, society would collapse, a victim to its own "excesses."

Though Chris Rock never said those words, he and millions of other leftists imply this belief with the value and importance they place on government.  They (unwittingly) become proponents of subservience to men.

This way of thinking is dangerous.  When we see men in positions of power as our "bosses" and our "daddies," as opposed to mere men, we raise them to a position in our hearts where they do not belong.  This eventually translates to elevating them to those same places in reality.  We end up conceding that we are incapable of governing ourselves without the help of some external force.

Unfortunately, the progressive looks to men to give them direction and make them better people.

Men who are flawed and prone to error.

Adolf Hitler. 
Men whose egos lead them to overestimate their value and abilities.  Many, if not most, leaders of history form cults of personality around themselves, leading up to and including actual worship.  Many become so enamored with themselves and what they believe they represent, they place themselves on pedestals over God Himself (or any god, for that matter).  In their own minds and in the minds of those who follow them closest, they become infallible and gods unto themselves.

Progressivism's fundamental weakness is its dependence on men to lead and solve problems, rather than each individual.  Their ethos leaves no room for God or individual choices.  By accepting other men as their "bosses," they leave themselves vulnerable to being controlled and destroyed by the men they look up to.



Quick footnote: My point (especially with the pictures), if you have not picked up on it, is that this mentality creates tyrants.  It creates men who control the people, people who, because they think this way, allow these things to happen.  This has nothing to do with Barack Obama, either.  This applies to any man or woman, historical or in the future, who is treated as a boss or father figure when they are merely the leader of an organization or country, no less mortal or flawed.

Monday, December 03, 2012

On Democracy Worship

"Pharaoh Morsi I...I like the sound of that."
For those of you blissfully unaware, on Thanksgiving Day, Egypt's new "president," Mohammad Morsi, issued several decrees to grant himself vast power over Egypt with virtually no oversight.  Now, under normal circumstances, I would take the next paragraph or two to mock the people who did not see this coming.  Only the willfully ignorant would have missed the signs (for example, Morsi being part of the organization that spawned both Al Qaeda and Hamas).  However, for those who fell for the deception of the "Arab Spring," there is a much more serious issue at hand than a few popular uprisings, which goes right to the core of their way of thinking.

That issue is "democracy worship."

What do I mean when I say that?

An opinion that seems to be very prevalent among liberals is that many of the world's problems would be solved if only it would embrace democracy more.  Hence, they tend to cheer any time a despot is overthrown to pave the way for "free" elections.  The most obvious example of this is the reaction to the "Arab Spring" uprisings, generally lauded by liberals while looked upon with apprehension by conservatives.

So, why was the latter so standoffish about these coups and rebellions while the former embraced them wholeheartedly?  After all, it sounds good when tyrants like Muammar Gaddafi and Hosni Mubarak are overthrown, doesn't it?

Note: He was voted into power.
The thing that large numbers of liberals fail to understand is that democratic (or republican) forms of governance are neither inherently good nor bad.  Truly, no form of government is inherently good or bad.  It largely dependent upon the people placed in charge and the ideologies they carry with them into positions of power.  It is true that totalitarian forms of government are far more likely to result in abusive tyrannies due to the corrupting influence of absolute power.  However, that is the government itself that gets corrupted, not the form of government.

As such, elections, even those that are free and trustworthy, can result in great evil being voted into power.  This proved true in the early 1930s, when the citizens of the Wiemar Republic voted the Nazi party into power, which eventually brought about World War II and the Holocaust.  This proved true in the late 2000s when the people of the Gaza Strip voted Hamas, a terrorist organization, into power, effectively turning the region into a epicenter of terror against Israel.

And now it has proven true in Egypt in 2012, as the people there, in a free election, voted Mohammad Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood into power.

Democracy is not a cure for society's ills.  It is subject to the whims and desires of the people under it.  If those people desire more freedom, they will vote it in.

If they desire more government control over their lives, they will vote that in.

If they desire a theocracy, they will vote that in.

Whatever people desire in democratic forms of government, they will eventually get.

If we truly wish to cure the ills of societies under dictators around the world, then the cultures of those societies must be changed.  The reason the American republic works is not because of the form of government we are under.  It is because we have people living in the republic who understand the importance of being stewards of their freedom.  They are vigilant and protect it from those who would undermine it.

Without that mentality, democracy is just another form of government, subject to be abused by the people in and under it.